Was Rand Fishkin’s Marriage Proposal a Marketing Ploy?

I’ve been reading the comments around the Internet on the TV wedding proposal last night. Of course, not everyone is happy for Rand and Geraldine. Reasons vary from hating public displays of affection to feeling robbed that the SuperBowl didn’t run the proposal, (I think whoever made that decision not to run it made a foolish mistake), to bickering that this was just a marketing tactic.

Was this just a marketing tactic?

Heck no. But, Rand and the people who helped him pull this stunt off do know how to work the system. What they did is to create an online portfolio of what they can do as marketers.

Rand went to incredible trouble to create a wedding proposal. Only he knows for sure what drove him. Yes, he deeply loves his fiance. And yes, he has sales blood in him.

It’s something I don’t have and could use a lot more of. I’m content to work behind the scenes. This is not the way with someone like Rand and people like him. They create a world of excitement that surrounds them wherever they go.

I was thinking about how SEOMoz.org can convert all the publicity into sales leads. I’m not saying they want to. What I’m saying is that from the perspective of their website, which is about their services, the steady stream of incoming traffic is usually coming to their blog. Today, there is gigantic horde of people visiting because of the wedding proposal videos and TV commerical last night.

Some people are commenting that this whole thing was done for “linkbait” or to be Dugg or otherwise hit the social media airwaves. I doubt this was the incentive, but it is certainly a by-product of doing something like this. However, rather than throwing a sales lead form at everyone during this period of time, Rand and Geraldine are off somewhere celebrating their engagement.

Could they convert these visitors to potential customers? Do they have call to action links on the blog thread persuading visitors to inquire about services while they are posting or reading congratulations posts? Is there momentum built into the SEOmoz blog to keep the multitude of people on their website?

No.

People can certainly linger on the SEOMoz site if they wish to, but most will watch the video somewhere else and never visit SEOMoz. If this was linkbait, it was misdirected to the wrong target market. How many web site owners watch the Veronica Mars show? I’ve never heard of it. Had it aired during the SuperBowl, how many viewers would have recognized Rand? The commercial never mentions his company or what he does for a living. Nor, does her “reaction video”.

Was the incentive a marketing ploy? I seriously don’t believe that. What he did demonstrate, along with the help of some marketing friends, is how this can be done. It took six months, a ton of money, travel, secrets, and a clever pre-run marketing campaign. They educated us by making their steps public (and raising funds for the Vanderbilt Childrens Hospital in the process), and Rand demonstrated the skills his company can bring to the table if you wish to hire them.

This is no longer the man who wears his trademark yellow shoes to conferences to be remembered.

Did this highly public proposal bring forth links? Gosh yes. Traffic? Definitely. The kind that makes servers cry. Will everyone know them wherever they go? Yes, for about two weeks and then they melt back into the universe again as regular folks.

Did they ask any of us to place an order for search engine marketing services after we viewed the videos?

No.

Sometimes the thing that drives us the most is loving somebody very much.

Stumble it!

Comments (5) to “Was Rand Fishkin’s Marriage Proposal a Marketing Ploy?”

  1. I will say that the Moz Squad will be relieved when the engagement hubbub dies down, because the planning for this has gone on for quite some time now and has exhausted all of us :)

    In regards to whether or not it was a marketing ploy, I think you hit the nail on the head with your explanation, Kim. If it were truly planned for commercial gain, we certainly could have done it differently in order to monetize from it. We didn’t though, which should be proof enough that it wasn’t the motive at all.

  2. I also hardly doubt the suspicions. People do a lot of bold and crazy things out of love. Given what I know now, I think it’s incredible that Rand was JP, but I wouldn’t have thought that there is any desire out of this for marketing referrals — just a desire that Rand has for Geraldine. I am really incredibly happy for them.

  3. Anyone who thinks Rand’s proposal was some sort of marketing ploy has obviously never met him.

  4. Great post, Kim. Couldn’t agree more. I could tell it was no ploy as soon as I watched the first video. I could try to explain why, but it would require me to reveal Secret Guy Stuff, and it looks like this thread is girls-only at the moment. :-)

  5. Of course the question of marketing and link-bait will come up when Rand does something like this :-). But… he’s extremely talented at this, he’s passionate about thinking in terms of marketing and link-bait, he’s doing what he loves doing and applying it to something that he really loves.

    It’s like a musician writing a song for his girl, like an artist painting a picture, like a gardener picking roses.

    It’s great to see people passionate! Go, Rand + Geraltine - keep that fire burning!

Post a Comment

Comments are moderated.

*Required
*Required (Never published)
 

Please check box to follow all comments.